How would a Democrat govern Florida? The top two candidates share their views
Chronicling the strange political currents of Florida and America
The Republican Party dominates every level of Florida government today. But that could change with the coming midterm elections this November. It has become virtually a theological “truth” among G.O.P. politicians these days that to survive in their party, they must swear allegiance to President Donald Trump. But Trump’s approval rating is in the toilet, and he could flush the careers of his sycophantic devotees. What would it look like if we elected a Democratic governor, even one serving with a Republican-dominated legislature? The leading candidates for the job, David Jolly and Jerry Demings, weighed in on that question. And their answers should give us hope. Here’s the report from today’s guest contributor, Mitch Perry of Florida Phoenix.
By Mitch Perry
David Jolly and Jerry Demings are vying to become the first Democratic governor to lead Florida in nearly three decades. If elected, they’ll face an additional challenge — working with an opposition Republican Party that enjoys a supermajority in the Legislature.
Speaking during a campaign event in Clearwater recently, Jolly mentioned a couple of specific ways he believes he could overcome that problem to deliver his policy goals, beginning with the power to name agency heads.
“Think about a state that come January [or] February we have a new surgeon general in charge of the state,” he said, referring to how he would jettison controversial Surgeon General Joseph Ladapo from his position on his first day in office.
“Think about an education commissioner who actually is going to have the backs of teachers and kids and books and academia and science and, yes diversity,” he continued. “Think about an environmental policy that is set by people that believe in environmental science. Think about an ethics and transparency office that actually begins to reveal the corrupt campaign finance system we have in the state of Florida, and yes, there’s a lot we can do.”
One lever of power that Democrats certainly should have learned from Gov. Ron DeSantis is executive authority, something that the Republican Legislature has rarely objected to during the past seven years. Among the decisions that DeSantis has made over the heads of the House and Senate was using taxpayer funds to send undocumented immigrants from Texas to Martha’s Vineyard in Massachusetts in 2022, and working with the federal government over the past year to create the detention facility for migrants dubbed Alligator Alcatraz (now on the verge of being closed down).
If elected, Jolly said, he intended to use the governor’s office to initiate litigation to boost the interests of the state.
“The attorney general exercises that authority. I don’t think the governor is precluded from exercising that authority, so I intend to … litigate a few things,” he said, specifically saying such litigation could include pushing for more access to reproductive care for women in Florida.
State law prohibits most abortions after six weeks of pregnancy, with some exceptions. More than 57% of Floridians voted to overturn that law in a constitutional amendment in 2024 — a clear majority but short of the 60% required for passage.
The Florida Democratic Party’s other major gubernatorial candidate, Jerry Demings, has also been thinking about how he could govern successfully with Republican-controlled Legislature.
“As mayor of Orange County, I’ve worked with Democrats and Republicans alike to get things done,” he said in a written statement to the Phoenix.
“As governor, I will be the bulwark against radical right-wing policies and force the Legislature to work on issues that matter to Floridians, such as affordability. And I will continue to work with local governments, the Florida Association of Counties, and the Florida League of Cities on issues of mutual interest.
“I will also not be afraid to wield the veto pen to stop the out-of-control tax-funded giveaways to special interests,” he added. “I will do everything I can to help end the supermajority and bring sane governance back to Tallahassee.”
Jolly also believes that if Floridians vote a Democrat into office as governor in November, they likely will also elect enough Democrats in legislative races to overcome the Republicans’ supermajority.
Trifectas
Florida is one of 23 Republican trifectas in the United States, where the state governor and legislature are of the same party. There are 16 Democratic trifectas and 11 divided governments in which neither party holds complete control.
Of those states, a handful feature a Democratic governor and a Republican legislature: Arizona, Kansas, Kentucky, North Carolina, and Wisconsin. Vermont has a Republican governor and Democratic-led Legislature.
In Kansas, Democratic Gov. Laura Kelly is finishing her eighth and final year in office working with a Republican-led Legislature.
Sherman Smith, editor of the Phoenix-affiliated Kansas Reflector, said Kelly was “totally underestimated” by Republicans during her first couple of years in office “and she got a lot of wins because of that.”
However, after the Kansas GOP expanded its supermajority in 2020, it’s been a much harder path for her to govern, Smith added.
And, since the 2024 election, that Republicans have “just entirely written her out of the process because they have strong enough members now, they just say, ‘We don’t even have to talk to the Democrats or tell them what we’re doing, or care what the governor thinks about it.’ They took the budget process away from her and a whole bunch of other stuff — what that means now it that they own it all.”
Kelly isn’t completely helpless: Following Kansas’ most recent legislative session earlier this year, she vetoed 24 bills and 31 budget line items.
In North Carolina, Democrat Josh Stein took office in January and is now working with a GOP-controlled General Assembly in Raleigh. Five months into his tenure, the results have been “mixed so far,” according to the Associated Press.
“The General Assembly passed storm-relief packages but gave Stein roughly a little over half the money he requested,” the AP reports. “It overrode several of his vetoes on bills that build up immigration enforcement, weaken transgender rights and assert other GOP priorities — results that Stein laments.”
It should be noted at this point that even with Republicans dominating state government, there have been plenty of clashes between the governor and the Florida House, in particular, since Gov. DeSantis won reelection but lost his presidential campaign in 2024.
For example, Gov. DeSantis a year ago vetoed more than half-a-billion dollars in projects from Republicans and Democrats alike in the 2025-26 fiscal year budget. That followed the Legislature overriding DeSantis’ veto of nearly $57 million for the Legislature’s operations in January 2025.
Republican Party of Florida Chair Evan Power says the whole discussion is academic.
“We now live in a ruby red state with 1.5 million more voters than Democrats,” he said in a text message. “Neither stands a chance to lead the free state of Florida.”
Another wrinkle is that Florida governor’s share executive power with the independently elected Florida Cabinet — the attorney general, chief financial officer, and agriculture commissioner, each office held by a Republican.
‘Let’s not waste time’
Jolly says that, if elected, he’ll immediately reach out to Florida’s Republican legislative leaders (who will be Jacksonville’s Sam Garrison in the House and Manatee County’s Jim Boyd in the Senate) and say, “Let’s not waste the next four years on behalf of the state. Let’s figure out how to work together.”
As a former Republican turned political independent who tried to build up a third political party before becoming a Democrat last year, Jolly says he’s in “a very post-partisan, post-ideological” phase in his life.
But that approach might be simpler said than done.
“We’re seeing a couple of Democrats running for governor this election year and talking about how he or they can reach across the aisle and work with the Republicans if they’re elected,” Smith said of what’s happening in Kansas this year. “But the reality is, the Republicans don’t want to work with them. And they don’t have to.”
Would the Republican-controlled Florida Legislature take a similar attitude following the shock of losing the governor’s mansion for the first time since 1994? We won’t know until November.
Mitch Perry, the reporter on this story, has covered politics and government in Florida for more than two decades. Most recently he is the former politics reporter for Bay News 9. He has also worked at Florida Politics, Creative Loafing and WMNF Radio in Tampa. He was also part of the original staff when the Florida Phoenix was created in 2018.
Florida Phoenix is part of States Newsroom, the nation’s largest state-focused nonprofit news organization. This story is republished with their permission. To support Florida Phoenix, click here:
Related:
David Jolly’s campaign website
Jerry Demings campaign website
Trump Approval falls to record low
Help make the midterms competitive
Not happy with the news coming out of Tallahassee? Do something about it.
The upcoming midterm elections provide a generational opportunity to change the complexion of Florida’s political makeup. But for that to happen, Republican candidates for the state Legislature must face opponents on the ballot.
Currently, there are far too many seats where Republicans are running unopposed. You can change that. You can decide to run. In which case, Project 140 can help you. Or you can pitch in and help fund those candidates who have already volunteered.
Thanks for your support
It’s easy to feel overwhelmed if you are a rational person living in the Free State of Florida, but there are plenty of smart, reasonable people just like you here. The purpose of this newsletter and the Tropic Press website is to provide a source of news and commentary that shines a light through this irrational fog, both original reporting and contributions such as today’s article from the Florida Phoenix.
Thank you for your support as a subscriber. It is invaluable. This is especially so for those of you who have chosen to upgrade to paid subscriptions. Your contributions are making this possible.
J.C. Bruce
Share Tropic Press!
As this newsletter was written, Tropic Press was reaching more than 700,000 subscribers in Florida and elsewhere. But there are literally millions of Florida Democrats and independents we are not reaching yet.
That’s a problem you can help solve.
With mid-term elections on the horizon, the more people we reach, the more effective we can be in helping turn our state and this country around. You can play a vital role in that effort by sharing this newsletter with friends.
If you are reading this as an email, simply forward it. Or you can use the link below. Thanks.
I've attended a Jolly rally last year and he's a political breath of fresh air. After 8 years of DeSantis' ultra right policies it's time to turn over the office to new ideas and political ideology. It's not so much a question of any one one party being right or wrong, it's more a question of balance. That balance is best provided by the constant "tug o' war" that a two party system can provide if we let it.
Government is a cooperative exercise. In a representative republic, which is what our ancestors (or, at least, my ancestors on my mother's side, who were here to fight in both Revolutionary and Civil wars) set up via the Declaration of Independence and U.S. Constitution, it takes cooperation between the Executive and Legislative branches to do anything substantive. The Judicial branch was set up to be the umpire that interprets the rules so everyone stays on the same page.
Note that neither document mentioned above says anything regarding political parties. That, and the left-right polarization they created are afterthoughts. The fact that we even care what party controls what branch is a bastardization of what was intended to be a delicately balanced system.
The Republican Party has explicitly said it wants to govern with no interference from their Democratic-Party rivals. That is exactly what the Constitution's framers were trying to avoid. Voters should take note of that. If GOP politicians don't want to participate in a cooperative government, voters should let them have their way by simply voting them off the island.
If someone doesn't want to participate in the cooperative enterprise of government, They don't have to participate by running for office. They can just sit on the sidelines and whine. We don't need them.